The Reporter Magazine
Tuesday, March 28, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Perspective
  • Op-ed
  • Commentary
  • The Brief
  • Business & Economy
  • Politics & Governance
  • Social
  • Sports
  • Science & Tech
  • Arts & Culture
  • Other
    • The View
    • Digits
    • From the Editor
The Reporter Magazine
No Result
View All Result

Egypt’s AU Chairmanship: a plain Sloganeering

Leulseged Girma by Leulseged Girma
April 6, 2020
in Op-ed
0
SHARES
79
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Egypt was elected to chair the African Union (AU) for the year 2019. Grabbing this opportunity, Egyptians were exhibiting excessive pride on their preparations and aspirations to revitalize the African continent through trade and infrastructure partnership and cooperation.  The theme of AU’s summit for the 2019 was focusing on “Refugees, Returnees and Internally Displaced Persons: Towards Durable Solutions to Forced Displacement in Africa”. The compatibility between the aspiration and the theme of the year was not seriously thought from the Egyptian side and Africa itself was silent on that. But there was one opportunity to fulfill the grand aspiration on infrastructural partnership and cooperation. That was the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) and the Nile Basin Cooperative Framework Agreement-CFA. But they missed it.

Egypt still advocates for the maintenance of status quo ante in consideration of the self-legitimatized 1929 and 1959 water agreements that estranged all the other Nile riparian states as sacrosanct. Such an unacceptable strategy left Egypt with individuality in the basin where reciprocity is highly compromised. The Nile Basin Cooperative Framework Agreement (CFA) provides a genuine legal and institutional platform for hydro-development anchored in hydro-equity. Egypt should primarily be committed to partnership platforms in its very domain (the Nile countries hydropolitical security complex) before embarking on a bigger pan-African platform. If Egypt aspires to play a constructive role through partnership and cooperative means, it should earnestly address this hydropolitical quagmire through interdependence and trust generation.  

Egypt’s plan to advance cooperation in terms of infrastructure and security is still an issue to be addressed in the Nile hydropolitical security complex where poverty, underdevelopment, insecurity and climate change issues boldly crop up. Ethiopia and the other Nile riparian states have shown immense commitment for the advancement of hydro-cooperation in the Nile basin countries representing more than forty percent of Africa’s population. Turning a deaf ear to this grand and venerated objective on the one hand and sloganeering “we are back to Africa” is self-contradictory and paradoxical. The Nile riparian states have provided a wider hydro-cooperation space to ensure sustainable development in the security complex. Egypt should politically and realistically ally itself with the Nile basin club where hands are still stretched to embrace a cooperative state of mind.

Does Egypt know the relationship between the theme of the AU summit for 2019 and the real situations in the Nile basin countries? Millions of people get internally displaced because of underdevelopment which can be changed through the wise and equitable use of natural resources. One way to do this would be for Egypt to recognize the very natural rights of the other Nile riparian states to effectuate the fair and equitable entitlement of the Nile waters. Egypt, a hegemonic state in the Nile basin, has been in a state of denial since time immemorial about water sharing with other co-basin states. Ethiopia, as a source of 85% of the Nile, has broken such a trend through the promotion of equitable use of water. Ethiopia did not take its geographic advantage by building grandiose dam projects, as Turkey has done, on its own soil. The country has long sought for the amalgamation of a state of mind for hydro-equity, own source of initiative and financial resources, incremental ideational power and national plan strategies to dilute Egypt’s hegemonic power. 

Egypt tried to garner support for its reputation from Africans while excluding the Nile issue from its engagement plan in the 2019 and beyond. Its new concentric circles of Pan-Africanism have a deep black hole at the common center where it doesn’t embrace the uninterrupted call for hydro-cooperation. Leaping forward by skipping the Nile issue doesn’t give it a stronghold in its conglomeration process of back to Africa. What is required from Egypt is principled win-win cooperation over the longest river in the world that is congruent with the universal aspiration of distributive justice in allocating international waters. If Egypt opts for partnership and cooperation, it should unconditionally join the CFA club and strengthen the common hydropolitical security. It is expected to discard its domineering ego. The only pragmatic way that can put an end to the impasse is to reconsider, sign and ratify the CFA that is embedded on the principles of fairness, equitability and win-win results. Undoubtedly, the Nile riparian states recognize the absolute necessity of the Nile waters to Egypt and its total dependence. They also know the rule and principle of ‘no significant harm’ that Egypt calls for now and then. Ethiopia is a unique example here because it has no intention whatsoever of using the Nile water resources unilaterally and in a disproportionate manner by bulldozing the rights of Egypt and other Nile riparian states.

While being stubborn, seeking to maintain the status quo ante of the colonial treaties in the Nile hydropolitical security complex at all costs (a very manageable security complex), Egypt has now appeared in a  reformative mood by looking for a fairer partnership and cooperation in Africa which is an aggregation of many security complexes including the Nile Basin. Discouraged by Egypt’s foot-dragging  tactics and urged by the level of poverty, unemployment and climate change, Ethiopia has been obliged to take unilateral development action that is  anchored in a ‘no significant harm’ mindset. The CFA is an opportunity for Egypt to demonstrate its commitment for sustainable human development in Africa through promoting normative, institutional and cooperative framework in the Nile basin countries.

Egypt has been accused of pursuing a realist approach in the Nile basin countries. It used its diplomatic and political leverages to deprive the other Nile riparian countries, especially Ethiopia, from obtaining loans and financial assistance to undertake hydraulic projects on the courses and sub-basins of the Nile that flow within Ethiopia. Of late, Egypt is employing technical delaying mechanisms especially on arguing on the timeframe for filling-up the reservoirs of the GERD and it also engulfs Ethiopia in the name of military cooperation in its neighborhood and acquiring a vast swathe of land from Djibouti.  

The CFA is a legal and institutional framework that helps to forge a cooperative and integrated management and development of the Nile waters. It has also been designed to pave the way in the creation of a permanent institutional mechanism, namely, the Nile River Basin Commission. As a principal riparian state on the Nile and in the Nile basin security complex, Egypt has to sign and ratify the CFA if it seeks long lasting partnership and cooperation. By so doing, it could serve as a catalyst for economic growth, poverty reduction, regional integration and the maintenance of peace and security in the basin and beyond. This is what real partnership and cooperation mean.

RELATED POSTS

The African Union Covid-19 Response Fund: a new social contract - The Reporter Magazine | Ethiopian Magazine

The African Union Covid-19 Response Fund: a new social contract

July 10, 2020
Police chief killed, 29 injured

Understanding Egyptian foreign policy and implications for Ethiopia

May 1, 2020

Renovating a supranational IGAD

April 18, 2020

ReckyaMadougou: a minister standing a self-made woman of Influence

April 26, 2020

Ethiopian firm in Kigali spearheads mutual business ties

April 6, 2020

Nile diplomacy: what is expected from the Ethiopian MPs?

April 26, 2020

As was expressed by its Ambassador in Addis Ababa at the end of 2018, Egypt’s chairmanship would have witnessed great efforts in resolving conflicts in Africa. But Egypt has never mentioned the conflicts over the Nile waters where it mostly confronts with the source country of the Nile, Ethiopia. The Ambassador was also reiterating that Egypt’s readiness to exercise preventive diplomacy that includes, inter alia, the prevention of existing disputes from escalating into conflicts. In reality, unfortunately, Egypt has not exhibited in easing tensions in the Nile bloc but has rather continued to detract, through various political approaches, the maturation of the CFA. As stated earlier on, the CFA is a normative framework that promotes preventive diplomacy. If Egypt accords importance to Africa and if it wants to promote partnership and cooperation, it should embrace the CFA even after its AU chairmanship tenure and contribute for the significant reduction of the sufferings of refugees and internally displaced persons in the Nile basin countries.

Ed.’s Note: Leulseged Girma is a researcher at Institute for Strategic Affairs (ISA). The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of The Reporter and ISA.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

The African Union Covid-19 Response Fund: a new social contract - The Reporter Magazine | Ethiopian Magazine
Op-ed

The African Union Covid-19 Response Fund: a new social contract

by Ebba Kalondo and Carl Manlan
July 10, 2020
0

The African Union recently rolled out the Partnership to Accelerate Covid-19 Testing (PACT)) building on the lessons from past outbreaks and epidemics. In early 2014,...

Read more
Police chief killed, 29 injured

Understanding Egyptian foreign policy and implications for Ethiopia

May 1, 2020
Police chief killed, 29 injured

Renovating a supranational IGAD

April 18, 2020
Police chief killed, 29 injured

ReckyaMadougou: a minister standing a self-made woman of Influence

April 26, 2020
Police chief killed, 29 injured

Ethiopian firm in Kigali spearheads mutual business ties

April 6, 2020
Police chief killed, 29 injured

Nile diplomacy: what is expected from the Ethiopian MPs?

April 26, 2020
Police chief killed, 29 injured

We must act now to reduce the likely impact of COVID-19 in Africa

April 26, 2020

RECOMMENDED

Ethiopia hell-bent on using the Nile - Ethiopian Magazine | Ethiopian News

Ethiopia hell-bent on using the Nile

May 1, 2020
Art in times political transitions

Digitalizing health care with medical apps

April 8, 2020
Race for space commercialization - Ethiopian Magazine | Ethiopian News

Race for space commercialization

May 1, 2020
Japanese economist advises Ethiopia to adopt quality production systems

Japanese economist advises Ethiopia to adopt quality production systems

March 31, 2020
Sir Richard John Roberts

Science Nobel Laureate Explains GMO

June 15, 2020

Follow us on Facebook

MOST VIEWED

  • Last call

    Last call

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Reality beyond the GERD rhetoric

    104 shares
    Share 104 Tweet 0
  • The abyss of graduate unemployment

    13 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 0
  • Ethiopia hell-bent on using the Nile

    4 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 0
  • Capturing award-winning emotions

    14 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 0
ADVERTISEMENT
The Reporter Magazine

The Reporter Magazine
Media & Communications Center
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
(+251) 116 61 61 85
[email protected]

CATEGORY

  • Arts & Culture
  • Business & Economy
  • Commentary
  • Digits
  • From the Editor
  • Op-ed
  • Perspective
  • Politics & governance
  • Science & Tech
  • Social
  • Sports
  • The Brief
  • The View
  • Uncategorized

Tags

Addis Ababa Africa coronavirus Covid-19 election 2020 EPRDF Ethiopia GERD Global Economy GMO IGAD lockdown Nile Oscar politics unemployment

NEWSLETTER

Get daily updates to all news reports, local and national coverage.
  • ሪፖርተር Ethiopian Reporter
  • The Reporter Ethiopia English
  • Reporter Tenders
  • Reporter Jobs
  • ሪፖርተር መጽሔት

Copyright © 2020 Media & Communications Center. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Homepage
  • Perspective
  • Op-ed
  • Commentary
  • The Brief
  • Business & Economy
  • Politics & governance
  • Social
  • Sports
  • Science & Tech
  • Arts & Culture
  • The View
  • Digits
  • From the Editor

Copyright © 2020 Media & Communications Center. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In